In Their Own Tongue: Missionary Tongues Revised
Missionaries sail from Los Angeles expecting the Spirit to give them the languages of China, Japan and Liberia. The paper’s unsigned editors report Lucy Farrow preaching in Kru, while its teachers urge order and interpretation by prayer. CTS traces how the Garrs and others found otherwise, and how Pentecostal missions turned to language study, interpreters and national leaders.
MUHTASARI WA CTSSoma muhtasari wote — unafunguka hapa hapa
"Kwa Lugha Yao Wenyewe": Lugha za Kimisionari na Misheni za Kuvuka Tamaduni“In Their Own Tongue”: Missionary Tongues and Cross-Cultural Mission
Somo la Seminari ya Kitheolojia ya Chapala — jinsi gazeti la Mtaa wa Azusa lilivyotumaini mwanzoni kwamba lugha zingeweza kuchukua nafasi ya kujifunza lugha, na jinsi misheni za Kipentekoste zilivyojifunza njia ya polepole na yenye hekima zaidi.A Chapala Theological Seminary reading — how the Azusa Street paper first hoped that tongues would replace language study, and how Pentecostal missions learned a slower and wiser way
Muhtasari wa CTS wa gazeti la kihistoria: "Pentecostal Missionary Reports" na "The Baptism with the Holy Ghost," The Apostolic Faith (Los Angeles), Buku la I Na. 11, Oktoba 1907–Januari 1908, kurasa 1 na 4; pamoja na "Unlocked by Prayer," Buku la I Na. 8, Mei 1907, ukurasa 3, na "Character and Work of the Holy Ghost," Buku la II Na. 13, Mei 1908, ukurasa 2. CTS inanukuu kwa ufupi tu maandishi ya wahariri na mafundisho yasiyotajwa majina, kwa ajili ya funzo na tafakari.A CTS digest of a historical periodical: “Pentecostal Missionary Reports” and “The Baptism with the Holy Ghost,” The Apostolic Faith (Los Angeles), Vol. I No. 11, October 1907–January 1908, pages 1 and 4; with “Unlocked by Prayer,” Vol. I No. 8, May 1907, page 3, and “Character and Work of the Holy Ghost,” Vol. II No. 13, May 1908, page 2. CTS quotes only unsigned editorial and teaching matter, briefly, for study and commentary.
- MisheniMissions
- Chanzo cha msingiPrimary source
- 1907–19081907–1908
- Lugha na kunena kwa lughaTongues and language
1.Gazeti Lililojaa Safari za Kuondoka1.A Paper Full of Departures
Toleo la kumi na moja la The Apostolic Faith lilifunika miezi minne, kuanzia Oktoba 1907 hadi Januari 1908, na ukurasa wake wa mbele ulikuwa umejaa kwaheri. Chini ya kichwa "Pentecostal Missionary Reports" (Ripoti za Kimisionari za Kipentekoste), wahariri walitaja orodha ya watenda kazi waliojazwa Roho walioondoka Los Angeles tangu gazeti lililopita: wamisionari kwenda Monrovia, Liberia, wanawake wawili kwenda China Kusini, na kikundi cha tisa kwenda China Kaskazini. Kikundi kingine cha kumi na wanne kilikuwa kimesafiri kutoka Spokane, Washington, kwenda Japani na China. Misheni ya Mtaa wa Azusa ilikuwa na umri wa miezi kumi na minane tu, na tayari ilikuwa ikifikiri kwa kutumia mabara. Ili kuelewa kwa nini, tunahitaji kukumbuka walichotarajia waumini hawa. Walikuwa na hakika kwamba Yesu anakuja upesi. Waliamini kwamba Injili lazima ihubiriwe kwa kila taifa kwanza (Mathayo 24:14). Na wengi wao waliamini kwamba Mungu alikuwa amewapa karama ambayo ingewezesha kazi hiyo katika kizazi kimoja.The eleventh issue of The Apostolic Faith covered four months, from October 1907 to January 1908, and its front page was crowded with farewells. Under the heading “Pentecostal Missionary Reports,” the editors listed Spirit-filled workers who had gone out from Los Angeles since the last paper: missionaries to Monrovia, Liberia, two women to South China, and a band of nine to North China. A further band of fourteen had sailed from Spokane, Washington, for Japan and China. The Azusa Street mission was barely eighteen months old, and it was already thinking in continents. To understand why, we need to remember what these believers expected. They were sure that Jesus was coming soon. They believed the gospel had to be preached to every nation first (Matthew 24:14). And many of them believed that God had just given them a gift that would make that task possible in a single generation.
2."Kwa Lugha Yao ya Asili": Tumaini la Mwanzo2.“In Their Native Language”: The Early Hope
Ripoti hiyo hiyo inaonyesha tumaini hilo waziwazi. Kuhusu kikundi cha Spokane, wahariri waliandika kwamba wamisionari walikuwa "wanaweza kuzungumza na Wachina na Wajapani bandarini na melini katika lugha zao za asili." Charles Parham, ambaye shule yake ya Biblia ya Topeka ilikuwa ya kwanza kuunganisha lugha na ubatizo katika Roho mwaka 1901, alifundisha kwamba lugha zilikuwa lugha halisi za wanadamu, zilizotolewa ili wamisionari wahubiri bila miaka ya masomo. Wanahistoria huita imani hii "lugha za kimisionari," au xenolalia, kutoka maneno ya Kigiriki yenye maana ya "usemi wa kigeni." Makala ya mafundisho ya ukurasa wa nne katika toleo hilo hilo, "The Baptism with the Holy Ghost," ilijenga hoja kutoka kwa Maandiko. Yesu alipowatuma kwanza wale kumi na wawili, inasema, aliwatuma kwa watu waliosema Kigiriki na Kiebrania: "Hawakuhitaji lugha za mataifa." Lakini baada ya Pentekoste agizo lilikuwa kwa ulimwengu wote, na siku ile ya kwanza "mataifa kumi na saba" walisikia Injili "kwa lugha zao wenyewe bila kuchanganyikiwa" (Matendo 2:9–11). Mwandishi anahitimisha kwamba Mungu "anafanya vivyo hivyo leo." Pentekoste ikiwa imerudi, hoja ilikwenda, Mungu angefanya tena.The same report shows that hope plainly. Of the Spokane band, the editors wrote that the missionaries were “able to talk to the Chinese and Japanese at the dock and on the ship in their native language.” Charles Parham, whose Topeka Bible school had first linked tongues with the baptism in the Spirit in 1901, taught that tongues were real human languages, given so that missionaries could preach without years of study. Historians call this belief “missionary tongues,” or xenolalia, from Greek words meaning “foreign speech.” The page-four teaching article in the same issue, “The Baptism with the Holy Ghost,” built the case from Scripture. When Jesus first sent out the twelve, it says, He sent them to people who spoke Greek and Hebrew: “They did not need the languages of the nations.” But after Pentecost the commission was to all the world, and on that first day “seventeen nationalities” heard the gospel “in their own tongue without confusion” (Acts 2:9–11). The writer concludes that God “is doing the same today.” If Pentecost had returned, the logic ran, God would do it again.
3.Lucy Farrow huko Liberia3.Lucy Farrow in Liberia
Mfano wa kina zaidi kwenye ukurasa wa mbele unamhusu Lucy Farrow (takriban 1851–1911), mhubiri mweusi wa utakatifu kutoka Houston ambaye alikuwa amesaidia kuleta ujumbe wa Kipentekoste Los Angeles mwaka 1906. Wahariri wanaripoti kwamba alikaa miezi saba huko Johnsonville, takriban maili ishirini na tano kutoka Monrovia, "katika hali ya hewa hiyo hatari kuliko yote," na sasa amerudi. Watu ishirini, wanasema, walipokea ubatizo katika Roho, na wengine waliokoka, walitakaswa na kuponywa. Kisha inakuja dai linalohusu somo hili: Bwana alikuwa amempa "karama ya lugha ya Kikru," na aliweza kuhubiri "mahubiri mawili kwa watu kwa lugha yao wenyewe." CTS inawasilisha hili kama ripoti ya gazeti, si ukweli uliothibitishwa. Hatujui nani aliihukumu lugha hiyo, au ni kiasi gani kilieleweka. Tunachoweza kusema ni kwamba safari ya Farrow ilikuwa halisi, ya gharama na ya ujasiri. Mwanamke mweusi aliye na umri wa miaka hamsini alivuka bahari kuhubiri Afrika Magharibi wakati ambapo bodi chache za misheni zingemtuma kabisa. Ukurasa huo huo wa mbele unaongeza sentensi iliyoathiri jinsi harakati ilivyojiona: "Hakuna mtu aliye kichwa cha harakati hii." Wahariri walimaanisha kwamba Roho, si mkurugenzi wa kibinadamu, ndiye aliyekuwa akiwatuma watu. Somo la 4 litaangalia maana yake kwa mpangilio wa kanisa.The most detailed example on the front page concerns Lucy Farrow (about 1851–1911), a Black holiness preacher from Houston who had helped bring the Pentecostal message to Los Angeles in 1906. The editors report that she spent seven months at Johnsonville, about twenty-five miles from Monrovia, “in that most deadly climate,” and had now returned. Twenty people, they say, received the baptism in the Spirit, and others were saved, sanctified and healed. Then comes the claim that matters for this reading: the Lord had given her “the gift of the Kru language,” and she was able to preach “two sermons to the people in their own tongue.” CTS presents this as the paper’s report, not a verified fact. We do not know who judged the language, or how much of it was understood. What we can say is that Farrow’s journey was real, costly and courageous. A Black woman in her fifties crossed an ocean to preach in West Africa at a time when few mission boards would have sent her at all. The same front page adds a sentence that shaped the movement’s view of itself: “There is no man at the head of this movement.” The editors meant that the Spirit, not a human director, was sending people out. Reading 4 will look at what that meant for organization.
4.Lugha, Utaratibu na Tafsiri4.Tongues, Order and Interpretation
Pamoja na tumaini la lugha za kimisionari, gazeti lilifundisha jambo la uangalifu zaidi. Mwezi Mei 1907 kipande cha mafundisho kisichotajwa jina, "Unlocked by Prayer" (Kufunguliwa kwa Maombi), kiliwaambia wasomaji kwamba Mungu hatoi "kitu kisicho na lugha au kisicho na maana." Lakini hakiwaambii watafute mgeni wa kuitambua. Kilisema kinyume: huna haja ya kutafuta mkalimani, kwa sababu "tafsiri hufunguliwa kwa maombi." Mwandishi kisha aligeukia 1 Wakorintho 14. Kanisa la Korintho, anasema, lilikuwa na bidii, na kila mtu alitaka kunena kwa lugha kwa wakati mmoja, hata wanaotafuta na wasiookoka waliachwa nje. Paulo alitaka utaratibu ili roho zifikiwe. Ukinena kwa lugha na huna tafsiri, makala inashauri, "unaweza kuketi ukampa mwingine nafasi." Yule anayesema "kwa lugha ya kawaida," inasema, ana thamani zaidi kwa mkutano. Huu ni busara ya kichungaji. Inachukulia lugha hasa kama maombi na sifa zinazoelekezwa kwa Mungu, ambazo zinahitaji tafsiri ili kuwajenga wengine, badala ya mahubiri tayari kwa wasikilizaji wa kigeni. Mawazo haya mawili yalikaa pamoja katika gazeti hilo hilo. Moja lilitazama nje kuelekea shamba la misheni; jingine lilitazama utaratibu wa mkutano wa mahali. Baadaye, la pili lingesaidia Wapentekoste kuelewa kilichokuwa kimekosea katika la kwanza.Alongside the hope of missionary languages, the paper taught something more careful. In May 1907 an unsigned teaching piece, “Unlocked by Prayer,” told readers that God does not give “that which is no language or has no meaning.” But it did not tell them to look for a foreigner who could identify it. It said the opposite: you need not hunt around for an interpreter, because “the interpretation is unlocked by prayer.” The writer then turned to 1 Corinthians 14. The Corinthian church, he says, was zealous, and everyone wanted to speak in tongues at once, so that seekers and the unsaved were left out. Paul wanted order so that souls could be reached. If you speak in tongues and have no interpretation, the article advises, “you may sit down and give somebody else a chance.” The one who speaks “in the plain tongue,” it says, is of more account to the assembly. This is pastoral common sense. It treats tongues mainly as prayer and praise addressed to God, which needs interpretation to build up others, rather than as a ready-made sermon for foreign listeners. The two ideas sat side by side in the same paper. One looked outward to the mission field; the other looked to the order of the local meeting. In time, the second would help Pentecostals understand what had gone wrong with the first.
5.Lugha Zilipokosa Kuja5.When the Languages Did Not Come
Katika shamba la misheni tumaini la lugha za papo hapo lilikutana na hali halisi haraka. Kisa maarufu zaidi ni cha Alfred G. Garr (1874–1944) na mkewe Lillian, wachungaji weupe wa utakatifu waliopokea ubatizo katika Roho katika Mtaa wa Azusa mwaka 1906 na kufika Calcutta, India, karibu na mwanzo wa 1907. Historia za kawaida zinaandika kwamba Garr alikuwa ametarajia kuhubiri kwa Kibengali na akagundua hakuweza. Yeye wala wamisionari wengi wa mwanzo hawakuweza kutumia lugha zao kuhubiri kwa watu waliowazunguka. Familia ya Garr haikurudi nyumbani. Walibaki, wakahudumu miongoni mwa wamisionari na Wakristo Wahindi, na mwaka 1907 walihamia Hong Kong, ambapo muumini Mchina, Mok Lai Chi, alifanya kazi nao kama mkalimani na baadaye akaongoza kazi yake mwenyewe ya Kipentekoste. Katika toleo la 9 ripoti ya Garr yenyewe kutoka India hata ilisema kwamba njia bora ya kusonga mbele ilikuwa kuwafikia wamisionari waliokwisha kuwa shambani, kwa sababu "wanajua desturi zote za India na pia lugha." Hilo lilikuwa badiliko la kimya lakini halisi la mkakati. Wanahistoria kama Gary B. McGee wamefuatilia jinsi, ndani ya miaka michache, viongozi wengi wa Kipentekoste waliacha kufundisha kwamba lugha ni njia ya mkato ya kujifunza lugha. Parham hakuiacha kabisa dhana hiyo, lakini harakati pana iliiacha. Iliendelea kushikilia imani yake kwamba lugha ni karama ya Roho na ikaja kuelewa hasa kuwa maombi na sifa "katika Roho" (1 Wakorintho 14:2), pamoja na tafsiri kwa kanisa.On the mission field the hope of instant languages met reality quickly. The best-known case is that of Alfred G. Garr (1874–1944) and his wife Lillian, white holiness pastors who received the baptism in the Spirit at Azusa Street in 1906 and reached Calcutta, India, around the turn of 1907. Standard histories record that Garr had expected to preach in Bengali and found he could not. Neither he nor most of the other early missionaries were able to use their tongues to preach to the people around them. The Garrs did not go home. They stayed, ministered among missionaries and Indian Christians, and in 1907 moved on to Hong Kong, where a Chinese believer, Mok Lai Chi, worked with them as interpreter and later led a Pentecostal work of his own. In issue 9 the Garrs’ own report from India even argued that the best way forward was to reach missionaries already on the field, because “they know all the customs of India and also the languages.” That was a quiet but real change of strategy. Historians such as Gary B. McGee have traced how, within a few years, most Pentecostal leaders stopped teaching that tongues were a shortcut to language learning. Parham never fully gave up the idea, but the wider movement did. It kept its conviction that tongues are a gift of the Spirit and came to understand them chiefly as prayer and praise “in the Spirit” (1 Corinthians 14:2), with interpretation for the church.
6.Kutoka Njia ya Mkato hadi Utii wa Muda Mrefu6.From Shortcut to Long Obedience
Kilichochukua nafasi ya njia ya mkato hakikuwa imani pungufu bali aina nyingine ya imani. Wamisionari wa Kipentekoste walianza kujifunza lugha kwa miaka, kufanya kazi na wakalimani, na zaidi ya yote kuwafunza waumini wazawa ambao tayari wanasema lugha ya watu wao wenyewe. Assemblies of God ilipoundwa mwaka 1914, misheni ilikuwa mojawapo ya madhumuni yake makuu, na kwa wakati wamisionari wake walikumbatia kanuni iliyoitwa "kanisa la asili" (indigenous church): makanisa shambani yanapaswa kuwa yanajitawala, yanajitegemea na yanajieneza yenyewe. Wapentekoste kama Alice Luce, aliyefanya kazi miongoni mwa watu wanaosema Kihispania huko Meksiko na Marekani, na baadaye Melvin Hodges, aliyehudumu Amerika ya Kati, waliipa muundo imara unaomtegemea Roho. Kipande cha mafundisho cha Mei 1908 katika gazeti la Azusa kilikuwa tayari kimeelekeza upande huu. Kikimwelezea Roho Mtakatifu, kilisema, "Tabia yake ni upendo," na kuongeza kwamba haishangazi watu "wanapata roho ya kimisionari mara tu wanapopata ubatizo." Upendo kwa watu ndio unaotuma wamisionari, na upendo kwa watu ndio unaowafanya wabaki kwenye kazi ngumu ya kujifunza lugha na utamaduni. Tumaini la mwanzo lilikosea kuhusu mbinu. Lilikuwa sahihi kwamba Roho hutoa mzigo kwa mataifa.What replaced the shortcut was not less faith but a different kind of faith. Pentecostal missionaries began to study languages for years, to work with interpreters, and above all to train national believers who already spoke the language of their own people. When the Assemblies of God was formed in 1914, missions was one of its central purposes, and over time its missionaries embraced what was called the “indigenous church” principle: churches on the field should become self-governing, self-supporting and self-propagating. Pentecostals such as Alice Luce, who worked among Spanish-speaking people in Mexico and the United States, and later Melvin Hodges, who served in Central America, gave it a strong Spirit-centred shape. A May 1908 teaching piece in the Azusa paper had already pointed in this direction. Describing the Holy Spirit, it said, “His character is love,” and added that it was no wonder that people “get the missionary Spirit as soon as they get the baptism.” Love for people is what sends missionaries out, and love for people is what keeps them at the hard work of learning a language and a culture. The early hope was wrong about the method. It was right that the Spirit gives a burden for the nations.
7.Kile Mchungaji au Mmisionari Anachochukua Leo7.What a Pastor or Missionary Takes from It Today
Mchungaji wa Kipentekoste huko Guadalajara, Nairobi au Seoul anachukua nini kutoka kurasa hizi? Kwanza, kwamba bidii na kosa vinaweza kuishi pamoja katika watu wa dhati. Wamisionari wa 1907 walikuwa jasiri na wenye kujitoa, na baadhi ya imani zao kuhusu lugha zilikuwa makosa. Tunaheshimu dhabihu yao bila kunakili makosa yao. Pili, kwamba Maandiko lazima yapime uzoefu, si kinyume chake. Kanisa lililosoma 1 Wakorintho 14 kwa uangalifu lilikuwa tayari zaidi kujisahihisha. Tatu, kwamba misheni inahitaji kuingia kwa subira katika hali ya watu. Yesu alijifunza lugha, aliishi katika utamaduni na alisema kwa semi za Galilaya. Wamisionari wanaojifunza lugha ya watu na kusikiliza hadithi zao wanafuata mfano wake. Nne, kwamba wajumbe bora mara nyingi ni waumini wa mahali. Familia ya Garr ilimhitaji Mok Lai Chi; Injili ilienea China kwa sauti za Wachina. Mchungaji anayetuma wamisionari leo anapaswa kuuliza watajifunzaje, watatumikia chini ya nani, na viongozi wa mahali watachukua uongozi lini. Tano, kwamba uaminifu kuhusu kushindwa huimarisha imani. Wapentekoste hawakuacha ubatizo katika Roho wazo la lugha za kimisionari liliposhindwa. Walikua kuwa na hekima zaidi.What does a Pentecostal pastor in Guadalajara, Nairobi or Seoul take from these pages? First, that zeal and error can live together in sincere people. The missionaries of 1907 were brave and devoted, and some of their beliefs about tongues were mistaken. We honour their sacrifice without copying their mistakes. Second, that Scripture must test experience, not the other way round. The church that read 1 Corinthians 14 carefully was better prepared to correct itself. Third, that mission requires patient incarnation. Jesus learned a language, lived in a culture and spoke in the idioms of Galilee. Missionaries who learn a people’s language and listen to their stories follow His pattern. Fourth, that the best messengers are often local believers. The Garrs needed Mok Lai Chi; the gospel spread through China by Chinese voices. A pastor who sends missionaries today should ask how they will learn, whom they will serve under, and how soon local leaders will take charge. Fifth, that honesty about failure strengthens faith. Pentecostals did not abandon the baptism in the Spirit when the missionary-tongues idea failed. They grew wiser.