A CTS digest — read the whole reading. (about 1,900 words)
Why Scripture must be interpreted (its clarity and its distance), the one goal (the author’s meaning), exegesis vs. eisegesis, and the humble, Spirit-taught, obedient heart the work requires.
CTS DIGESTRead the full digest — opens right here
Why We Interpret, and the Heart of the Interpreter
A Chapala Theological Seminary reading — the goal of interpretation, and the kind of person the Bible asks us to be
A CTS-authored survey, anchored in Milton S. Terry's Biblical Hermeneutics (1883) and John Owen's treatise on understanding the mind of God in His Word (1678), both public domain, and in Scripture.
- Hermeneutics
- The Goal of Interpretation
- The Interpreter's Heart
- Anchored in classics
1. Why Interpret at All?
The Bible is clear in its central message. Its way of salvation is plain enough that a child or an unlettered believer can read it and be saved; this is what the church has called the "perspicuity," the clearness, of Scripture. God did not hide the road to heaven in riddles that only scholars could solve; the great matters — that we are sinners, that Christ died and rose for us, that we are called to repent and believe — lie on the surface of the Book for anyone who will read with an honest heart. This is a mercy we must never forget, and it should keep us from ever making interpretation sound like a locked room to which only the learned hold the key.
And yet the same Bible was written thousands of years ago, in languages we do not speak, among customs we do not share, and in many different forms of writing — and some of it is genuinely hard. A letter written to first-century believers in Corinth or Rome assumed a world of shared knowledge that we no longer possess; a prophet's vision, a psalm's imagery, a law given to ancient Israel — these do not always yield their meaning at a glance. Even the apostle Peter admitted that Paul's letters contain "some things hard to understand," which the unstable twist to their own destruction. So the Word must be interpreted: we must work, carefully and prayerfully, to grasp what God — speaking through the human writers — actually meant.
Here is a truth to settle at the very outset: everyone who reads the Bible interprets it. The person who says, "I don't interpret, I just read what it says," is interpreting too — only without knowing it, and therefore without care. The only question is never whether we interpret, but whether we do it well or badly, with method or by whim. Hermeneutics is simply the discipline of doing it well: of reading in a way that honors what the text is, so that we hear God's voice and not the echo of our own. Far from being a barrier between the believer and the Book, it is the servant that helps him hear the Book more clearly.
2. The One Goal: the Author's Meaning
What are we after when we interpret? One thing above all: the meaning the author intended. We want to know what the writer, moved by the Holy Spirit, meant to say to his first readers — and, through that meaning, what God is saying to us. The meaning of a passage is not a soft and shifting thing that each reader shapes for himself; it was fixed by the one who wrote it, and our task is to find it, not to make it. This single aim rules out a whole world of mischief. We do not come to make the text say what we wish it said, nor to find in it whatever thought happens to strike us as we read.
There is a popular way of speaking that quietly undoes all of this — the question, "What does this verse mean to me?" as though a passage might mean one thing to me, another to you, and a third to the next reader, each equally valid. But a text has one meaning, the meaning its author gave it; what changes from reader to reader is not the meaning but the application, and we will come to that distinction in its place. For now, fix this firmly: the interpreter is a listener before he is anything else. He comes as a servant, to receive the meaning that is really there, placed there by God Himself — not as a master, to bend the words to his own purposes. The moment we forget this, the Bible stops speaking to us and begins merely repeating us.
3. Exegesis, Not Eisegesis
The old teachers marked this with two words worth remembering. Exegesis means to lead out — to draw out of a passage the meaning that God put in it. Eisegesis means to lead in — to read into a passage a meaning that is not there, importing our own ideas, our favorite doctrines, or the fashions of our age, and dressing them up in the words of Scripture. All faithful interpretation is exegesis; all the abuse of the Bible is, at bottom, eisegesis. The two words sound alike, and the difference between them is one small syllable — but that syllable is the whole difference between hearing God and using God.
Eisegesis is rarely done on purpose; that is what makes it dangerous. A man comes to a text already sure of what he wants it to say — because his tradition taught it, or his experience suggests it, or it would be useful in his sermon — and he finds it there, whether it is there or not. The words become a mirror in which he sees only his own face. The remedy is a constant, honest self-suspicion: to ask, at every step, "Am I drawing this out of the passage, or reading it in? Would the author recognize what I am claiming he said?" The interpreter's constant temptation is to master the text — to make it echo back his own voice. His constant duty is the opposite: to sit under the text, and let it master him. A good interpreter is a humble one, forever ready to be surprised and corrected by what he finds.
4. The Heart the Bible Asks For
And this is why interpretation is never a merely technical skill, like learning a trade. A man may know Greek and Hebrew, own every commentary, and still miss the true sense of the Word, if his heart is wrong; while a humble believer with few tools may be led by the Spirit into deep and saving understanding. The old Puritan John Owen taught that to understand the mind of God in His Word, a man needs more than tools; he needs a certain heart — and the conditions Owen named are spiritual, not merely intellectual.
He needs humility — to come and sit beneath the Word, ready to be corrected by it, not standing over it as its judge. He needs dependence on the Holy Spirit — for the same Spirit who inspired the Scriptures must open our blind eyes to see what is there; the natural mind cannot receive the things of God, so we pray, before we study, for light. He needs reverence, approaching God's own Word not as a puzzle to be cracked or a quarry to be mined for sermon material, but as holy ground, with awe. And, above all, he needs the aim of obedience. Jesus gave the secret Himself: "If anyone wills to do His will, he shall know." There is a moral condition to understanding: the person who comes willing to obey whatever he finds is the person God leads into the truth, while the one who comes only to gather ammunition, or to satisfy curiosity, is often left in the dark.
This should shape how a pastor prepares. Before he opens his lexicons, let him open his heart; before he studies the text, let him pray to be made willing to bow to it. The most important preparation for handling the Word is not a full shelf but a soft heart — and that is within the reach of the poorest and least-schooled believer, as much as of the greatest scholar. It is the willing, obedient, praying heart, more than the clever mind, that God leads into the truth.
None of this, rightly understood, is an excuse for laziness. To lean on the Spirit is not to neglect the study, as though prayer could replace the patient work of understanding the words; the same God who gives light also gave us minds and expects us to use them, and He is pleased to bless the diligent, not the careless. Nor is hard study a substitute for prayer, as though a good method could open a blind heart. The two belong together: we work as hard as if everything depended on our study, and we pray as humbly as if everything depended on the Spirit — because, in truth, both are His gifts, and He has joined them. The interpreter who prays but will not labor, and the one who labors but will not pray, both fall short; the faithful one does both, and leaves the increase to God.
5. Why It Matters, Especially for Pastors
All of this presses hardest on those who preach and teach. The pastor stands up with the Book open before God's people, and what he tells them it means, they will believe and live by. They cannot all check him; many will simply trust that he has handled the Word faithfully, and they will build their lives — their hopes, their obedience, their view of God — on what he says it means. To handle it carelessly, or to bend it to his own ends, is not a small fault; it is to mislead the very souls placed in his care, and to answer for it before the God whose Word he claimed to speak.
Paul's charge to the young pastor Timothy has never grown old: "Be diligent to present yourself approved to God, a worker who does not need to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth." There is honest labor in those words — be diligent, be a worker — and there is a warning in them too, for the alternative to rightly dividing is to be ashamed before God for mishandling His Word. Every rule of interpretation we will learn in this course has one purpose: to help us hear more clearly what God has actually said, so that we may obey it ourselves and faithfully feed His flock. The methods are not ends in themselves; they are the tools of a servant who trembles at the weight of speaking for God, and who would rather be plain and true than clever and wrong.
Let this first lesson settle deep, then, before all the rules that follow: we read in order to hear, we listen in order to obey, and we ask God for the humble and willing heart that alone can truly understand His Word.
6. Taking It to Heart
For reflection. Be honest: when you come to a passage, do you come mostly to hear what God says — or to find support for what you already think? Where might you have been reading into the Bible rather than drawing out of it? And will you begin your study, from now on, by praying for the humble, obedient, Spirit-taught heart that true interpretation requires?