The Preacher Himself: Character and the Inner Life
Why who the preacher is matters as much as what he says: truth through personality, taking heed to yourself, the perils of the pulpit, and holiness above gifts.
CTS DIGESTRead the full digest — opens right here
The Preacher Himself: Character and the Inner Life
A Chapala Theological Seminary reading — why who the preacher is matters as much as what he says
A CTS-authored survey, anchored in Phillips Brooks's Lectures on Preaching (1877) and C. H. Spurgeon's Lectures to My Students (1875), both public domain, and in Scripture.
- Preaching
- The Preacher's Character
- Truth Through Personality
- Anchored in classics
1.Truth Through Personality
Phillips Brooks gave preaching its most famous definition: it is the bringing of truth through personality. Both halves are essential, and neither may be lost. What is preached must be God’s truth, not the preacher’s own notions dressed up as revelation. But that truth does not fall from heaven onto the pew; it comes through a person — a living, believing, consecrated man who has first received it himself.
This is why preaching can never be reduced to reciting correct words, as a machine might. The messenger and the message are joined. What the preacher is will color everything he says, for good or for ill, and the people will feel it even when they cannot name it. The same truth, from a shallow man, sounds thin; from a deep and holy man, it carries weight, because it comes soaked in a life. God has chosen to send His truth not on paper alone, but through living men, so that what they are becomes part of how His Word is heard.
This should make a preacher tremble, but it should also draw him upward. If the truth comes through the man, then the best thing a preacher can do for his preaching is to become, himself, a better and holier man — more full of Christ, more shaped by the Word, more consecrated to God. There is no separating the two: to grow as a Christian is to grow as a preacher, and the deepening of the man is the deepening of the message he carries. The improvement of the sermon begins with the improvement of the soul.
2.Take Heed to Yourself First
Spurgeon opened his famous lectures to young preachers not with sermon-craft but with “The Minister’s Self-Watch” — and he was following Paul, who charged Timothy, “Take heed to yourself and to the doctrine” (1 Timothy 4:16), putting the self before the sermon. The order is deliberate, and it is easily reversed. Most preachers give the greater part of their care to the sermon and only the smaller to the soul; Paul, and Spurgeon after him, would have it the other way.
The preacher’s private walk with God, his secret devotion, his honesty in small things, his purity of heart — these are the hidden foundation on which all his public work rests. A man may preach the truth with a golden tongue, but if his life flatly contradicts it, he pulls down with his hands what he builds with his lips. The pulpit is no place for a divided life; and a congregation, over time, is shaped far more by what its preacher is than by what he says. Who he is on Monday preaches louder, in the end, than what he says on Sunday.
This is not to say that gifts and preparation do not matter; they do, and this course has labored over them. But they are the second thing, not the first. A holy man with modest gifts will, over a lifetime, do more lasting good than a gifted man whose heart is cold; for the people receive not only his words but himself, and what he is seeps into all he does. So the wise preacher gives his first and best attention to what he is before God, knowing that everything else grows out of that root.
3.The Perils of the Preacher
R. W. Dale warned of the special dangers that stalk those who preach — perils that grow, strangely, out of the very holiness of the work. There is pride, feeding on the praise of the crowd, for the man who is often listened to and admired is in constant danger of thinking too well of himself. There is professionalism — the deadly habit of handling holy things as a mere job, until the fire goes out and only the routine remains, and a man can discuss the deepest truths without feeling any of them.
There is the temptation to preach in order to be admired rather than to save, so that the preacher’s eye is on his own reputation and not on his hearers’ souls. There is the slow loss of personal freshness with God, so that a man speaks of a fountain from which he himself has stopped drinking. And there is discouragement, which can wither a faithful heart over years of hard and often unrewarded labor. To name these perils is the first step in guarding against them; the preacher who knows where the pits lie can walk around them, while the one who never suspects them falls in.
Of these perils, professionalism may be the most quietly deadly, because it looks so much like faithfulness. A man keeps preaching, keeps studying, keeps doing all the outward work — and yet somewhere the life has drained out of it, and he handles the things of God as a clerk handles papers. The guard against it is to keep coming to the truth as a worshiper and not merely a workman: to let the passage he prepares first do its work on him, to be moved himself before he asks others to be moved, and to refuse to speak of Christ in public without seeking Christ in private.
4.Holiness Above Gifts
It is a lesson the church learns and forgets and must learn again: God uses holy men more than merely gifted ones. Gifts dazzle, but godliness bears fruit that lasts. A brilliant sermon may be admired and forgotten by the next morning; a holy life preaches on for years, and its influence outlives the man.
The young Scottish pastor Robert Murray M’Cheyne left the church a sentence worth writing on the study wall: “My people’s greatest need is my personal holiness.” A preacher’s usefulness rises and falls, in the long run, not with the brilliance of his mind but with the reality of his walk with God. Great gifts joined to a small soul are a danger to their owner and to the church — for the gifts win a hearing that the character cannot sustain, and the fall, when it comes, is the greater for the height. Better a plain man who is holy than a dazzling one who is hollow.
There is a reason holiness carries such weight, beyond the good example it sets. A holy preacher is a man in living contact with God, and something of that contact is communicated through him — a savor, a seriousness, an authority that mere technique can never produce. When a man walks closely with God in secret, his preaching comes from that nearness, and the people sense they are hearing from someone who has been with the Lord. It is not that holiness makes a man eloquent; it is that it makes him real, and reality in the pulpit is worth more than all the polish in the world.
5.Keeping the Heart
All this drives the preacher to tend his own inner life with care. He must pray in secret, and not only prepare prayers for others. He must feed on the Scriptures for his own soul, and not merely quarry them for sermons — for a man may spend all his hours in the Bible and yet starve, if he reads it only to find something to say and never to be fed himself.
He must keep short accounts with God, quick to repent, walking humbly. In a word, he must be a Christian before he is a preacher, and remain one underneath all his labors — for “out of the heart are the issues of life” (Proverbs 4:23), and a preacher who does not keep his own heart will soon have nothing living to give. The care of his own soul is not one duty among many for the preacher; it is the spring from which all his ministry flows, and if that spring is guarded, the stream will be clean and full, but if it is neglected, no skill will keep the water pure.
6.Grace for the Preacher
If all this feels weighty, take heart: the standard is high, but the grace is higher. No man steps into the pulpit as one who has arrived; every faithful preacher stands there as a forgiven sinner pointing away from himself to the Savior he needs as much as anyone in the room. The call to holiness is not a call to pretend a perfection we do not have, but to walk honestly with God, confessing our failures and leaning on His mercy.
The aim is not a flawless life — none of us has that — but an honest, growing, God-fearing one, and a heart that runs back to grace whenever it fails. It is this kind of man, kept and cleansed and humbled by his own gospel, whom God delights to use. Indeed, there is a peculiar power in the preaching of a man who plainly lives on the grace he offers to others — who is not a lofty saint looking down, but a rescued sinner reaching out a hand to fellow sinners, saying, in effect, “Come with me to the mercy that has held me.” So let no preacher be crushed by the height of the calling; let him rather be driven by it, again and again, to the Christ who both saves him and sends him.
This grace also keeps the whole high calling from becoming a burden of despair. A preacher who felt he had to be sinless before he could preach would never preach at all, or would preach as a hypocrite pretending a holiness he lacked. But the gospel he proclaims is for him first: he preaches as a forgiven man, kept by mercy, growing slowly, failing and repenting and rising again like every other believer. That honesty is not a weakness in his ministry but a strength, for it keeps him humble, keeps him kind toward strugglers, and keeps him near to the grace that alone makes any of us fit to speak for God at all.
And so the course that began with the shaping of a message ends with the shaping of a man — for in the end the two cannot be pulled apart. Give God your best craft; but give Him, first and last, yourself. It is holy men, kept by grace, whom He most delights to send.