What Is True Church Growth?
Defining the growth God gives: more than numbers (a church may be large yet shallow, or small yet healthy — Bannerman); growth in depth as well as breadth (growing up into Christ); the marks of a healthy church; true conversions, not mere additions; the peril of worldly measures (the church is not a business); rightly ordering the two (numbers not despised, but sought as the fruit of faithfulness); and growth that pleases God.
CTS DIGESTRead the full digest — opens right here
What Is True Church Growth?
A Chapala Theological Seminary reading — seeking the growth God gives, not mere numbers
A CTS-authored survey, anchored in the classic public-domain works on the nature and health of the church (James Bannerman's The Church of Christ, and others), and in Scripture.
- Church Growth
- True Growth Defined
- Health, Not Mere Numbers
- Anchored in classics
1.A Word That Needs Defining
Before we can wisely pursue the growth of the church, we must ask a question that is too often skipped: what do we actually mean by church growth? The phrase can be understood in very different ways. To some it means simply larger numbers — bigger crowds, fuller buildings, more members on the roll. To others it means something deeper: the spread of the gospel, the making of true disciples, the maturing of believers, the health and faithfulness of the church. These are not the same thing, and they may even pull in different directions, for it is possible to increase the numbers while neglecting the health, or to build a large gathering that is spiritually weak. So before we set out to seek church growth, we must be clear about what growth we are seeking, lest we labor for the wrong thing. A shallow definition will lead to shallow labors and shallow results. The whole course before us assumes that we want true church growth — the kind that God gives and delights in — and so it is worth beginning by defining what that is. This first reading, then, seeks to lay a right foundation by asking what true church growth really is, so that all our later efforts may be aimed at the right target.
2.More Than Numbers
The first thing to say is that true church growth is more than a matter of numbers. This must be said plainly, because in our day the temptation is strong to measure a church simply by its size, and to call a church "successful" or "growing" merely because its numbers are rising. But numbers alone tell us very little about the real state of a church. A church may grow large while remaining spiritually shallow, worldly, or even unfaithful to the gospel; and a church may be small yet spiritually healthy, faithful, and pleasing to God. Size and health are not the same. James Bannerman, in his careful study of the nature and marks of the church, helps us see that the church is defined not by its numbers but by deeper things — by its relation to Christ, its faithfulness to the truth, and the marks of genuine spiritual life. To measure the church by numbers alone is to use a shallow and misleading gauge. This does not mean numbers are unimportant, as we shall see; but it means they must never be our only or our chief measure. A right view of church growth begins by refusing to equate growth with mere numerical increase, and by looking deeper.
3.Growth in Depth as Well as Breadth
True church growth includes not only breadth — more people — but depth — deeper people. A church grows not only by adding members but by its members growing up into Christ. The New Testament speaks constantly of this inward growth: of believers maturing, growing in grace and in the knowledge of God, being built up in love, and growing up in all things into Christ, who is the head. This maturing of believers is as much a part of true church growth as the adding of new ones, and perhaps more fundamental, for a church that is not growing in depth will not long grow rightly in breadth. Both belong to genuine growth: the church grows out, as new people are brought in, and it grows up, as its people mature. And the two must be held together; depth must never be sacrificed for breadth, nor breadth pursued at the cost of depth. A church swelling in numbers but shrinking in spiritual maturity is not truly growing but declining, whatever the figures say. So when we think of church growth, we must think of both dimensions: the increase of the church in number, and the maturing of the church in grace. True growth is the church growing up into Christ, as well as growing out into the world.
4.The Marks of a Healthy Church
If true growth is the growth of a healthy church, we must ask what a healthy church looks like. Here again Bannerman's study of the marks of the church is a help, directing us to the deeper signs of genuine spiritual life rather than to mere outward success. A healthy church is one built upon the Word of God, where the Scriptures are faithfully taught and believed; where God is truly worshiped; where the ordinances the Lord gave His church are rightly observed; where there is loving fellowship among the members; where holy living is pursued; where prayer ascends; and where the gospel is carried to those outside. These are the marks of a church that is spiritually alive and well, and they matter far more than mere size. A small church marked by these things is healthier, and dearer to God, than a large one that lacks them. The wise pursuit of church growth, therefore, aims first at these marks of health, for it is out of a healthy church that true and lasting growth springs. We do not chiefly ask, "Is our church large?" but, "Is our church healthy — faithful to the Word, alive in worship, growing in love, given to prayer, active in witness?" Where these marks are present, there is true life, and there true growth may be expected.
5.True Conversions, Not Mere Additions
When the church does grow in numbers, we must ask further what kind of increase it is. True church growth involves real conversions — people genuinely turning to Christ in repentance and faith, born again by the Spirit of God — not merely names added to a roll, or crowds gathered by other attractions. It is possible to increase a gathering without adding a single true believer, by drawing people through entertainment, novelty, or the offer of earthly benefits, so that the numbers rise while true spiritual life does not. Such increase is not real church growth, however it may look, for the church is the company of those who truly belong to Christ, and only genuine conversion adds to it in God's sight. We must therefore long not merely for more people, but for people truly saved; not for apparent fruit, but for real fruit; not for decisions lightly made and soon forgotten, but for lives genuinely turned to Christ by the Spirit's work. This is a searching test of our aims. Do we rejoice in mere numbers, or in true conversions? The growth that pleases God is the growth of His true church, as real sinners are really saved and added to the people of God.
6.The Peril of Worldly Measures
There is a real peril to guard against here: the peril of borrowing the world's measures of success and applying them to the church. The world measures success by size, numbers, popularity, wealth, and impressiveness; and it is dangerously easy to carry these measures into the church, and to judge a congregation as we might judge a business or a public gathering. But the church is not a business to be grown by clever marketing, nor is its success to be reckoned as a company reckons its profits. The Lord does not see as man sees; man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart. God's measures of a church's health and success are not the world's measures, and to adopt the world's measures is to be led astray at the very start. A church may be counted a great success by worldly standards and yet be poor and weak in the sight of God; and a church may seem small and unimpressive to the world and yet be rich and pleasing to Him. The pursuit of church growth must therefore be freed from worldly measures of success, and governed instead by God's own measures — faithfulness, holiness, true conversions, and spiritual health. To measure the church as the world measures is to pursue the wrong thing entirely.
7.Rightly Ordering the Two
Having said all this, we must not swing to the opposite error of despising numbers altogether, as though the size of the church did not matter at all. Numbers are not to be scorned, for behind every number is a soul, and the addition of true believers to the church is a good and joyful thing. Scripture itself records the numbers of those added in the early church, and rejoices in them; there is joy in heaven over even one sinner who repents, and surely joy over three thousand. So we do not despise the ingathering of many; we long for it. The point is not that numbers do not matter, but that they must be rightly ordered — sought as the fruit of faithfulness and the work of the Spirit, not as an end in themselves or pursued by any means. We long for growth in numbers, but as the overflow of a healthy church and the fruit of true conversions, not as a substitute for health, nor as a prize to be won by worldly methods. When numbers rise as the fruit of faithful, healthy, Spirit-filled church life, they are a cause for great rejoicing. It is only the pursuit of numbers apart from health, or in place of health, that we must refuse. Rightly ordered, the increase of the church is a blessing devoutly to be desired.
8.Growth That Pleases God
Let us gather all this into a single aim: the growth we seek is the growth that pleases God. It is true conversions, as real sinners are saved by grace; the maturing of believers, as they grow up into Christ; the health of the church, marked by faithfulness to the Word, true worship, loving fellowship, prayer, and witness; and, flowing from these, the increase of the church in number, as the Lord adds to His people. This is the growth God gives and delights in, and this is what we set ourselves to seek. Before we ask how the church grows — which the rest of this course will consider — we settle what growth we are seeking, and we settle it thus: not mere numbers, not worldly success, but the true, deep, healthy growth that comes from God. The Lord Jesus said that His Father is glorified when His people bear much fruit; and it is fruit that abides, real and God-given, that we long to see. With this right aim before us, we may go on to consider, in the readings that follow, how such growth is to be sought. Let us seek the growth that God delights to give, to the glory of Christ, who builds His church.