The call to a wholehearted rather than half-hearted religion; what real devotion is — all of life ordered to please God, not a compartment kept beside a worldly life; the inconsistency of being devout in prayer but worldly everywhere else; living to please God in everything. Grace-framed: devotion as glad surrender flowing from grace, not works to earn it.
CTS DIGESTRead the full digest — opens right here
A Serious Call: The Devout and Holy Life
A Chapala Theological Seminary reading — living wholly for God, not a half-hearted religion
A CTS-authored survey, anchored in William Law's A Serious Call to a Devout and Holy Life (1729, public domain), and in Scripture.
- Practical Theology
- The Devout Life
- Living Wholly for God
- Anchored in a classic
1. A Serious Call
It is entirely possible to be a Christian in name, and even to be quite careful about one's prayers and one's churchgoing, while living a religion that is really only half-hearted — comfortable, respectable, nominal, and undemanding, touching the surface of life but never disturbing its depths. This is a danger in every age, and perhaps especially where the faith is old and familiar and costs little socially to profess. It is the danger of a religion that has become a habit rather than a life.
In 1729 William Law wrote a book that confronted this comfortable, nominal Christianity with unusual force and directness, and its very title carries its whole message: A Serious Call to a Devout and Holy Life. Law's central conviction was at once simple and deeply searching. God does not call His people, he insisted, to a casual, part-time, Sunday-only religion, but to a serious and wholehearted life of devotion — to belong to Him entirely, and to live for Him not on Sundays and at prayer times only, but in the whole ordinary substance of everyday life. It is a call very much worth hearing afresh in our own day, for it is fatally easy to drift, almost without noticing, into a faith that costs us little, changes us less, and slowly hardens into mere religious routine. Law will not let us rest there.
2. What Devotion Really Is
Law began his book by asking a simple question — what a truly devout person actually is — and his answer quietly overturns the assumption most people carry. A devout person, he said, is not merely one who prays a great deal, or who is much occupied with religious exercises — though of course such a person will certainly pray, and pray earnestly. To reduce devotion to the time we spend in prayer is to miss its real meaning entirely.
A devout person, Law taught, is rather one who lives the whole of life unto God: who takes his entire life — his daily work, his ordinary pleasures, his time, his money, his conversation, his plans — and deliberately orders every part of it to please and honor God. Devotion, in other words, is not something confined to prayer times or shut up within the walls of a church building; it is the whole shape and direction of a life that has been turned Godward. This is a far larger and more demanding thing than most of us mean by the word. True religion, on this account, is not one carefully kept compartment of a person's life, however sincere that compartment may be; it is the entire life itself, every hour of it, offered up and lived for the glory of God. That is what it means to be devout.
3. The Inconsistency Law Exposed
From this understanding, Law pressed home a single uncomfortable point that has stung and searched his readers for three full centuries, and searches us still. Many Christians, he observed with painful accuracy, are genuinely strict and diligent in their prayers and their worship — no one could fault their Sunday devotion — and yet live all the rest of their lives — their work, their spending, their leisure, their speech, their ambitions — very much as the unbelieving world around them does, with scarcely any reference to God at all. They are devout in the closet and worldly in the street.
And Law asked the plain, obvious, uncomfortable question that such a life invites: why be so careful to be devout in the hour of prayer, but so careless everywhere else? Why serve God diligently for one hour on Sunday and then live the other hundred-and-sixty-seven hours of the week almost exactly as though He did not exist? It is, when we look at it honestly, a plain and glaring inconsistency, and Law would not let his readers look away from it. His logic is simple and hard to escape: if God is worth serving carefully at all, in the closet, then He is worth serving in everything, everywhere. Real devotion refuses to carve life up into a "religious" part that belongs to God and a much larger "secular" part that we quietly keep for ourselves; it knows, and lives as though it knows, that all of life, and all that we are and have, belongs wholly to Him.
4. Living to Please God in Everything
Here we come to the intensely practical heart of the whole matter. The devout Christian, Law teaches, learns to carry one single question into every corner and department of life — into his work and his money, his leisure and his speech, his plans and his relationships and his rest: how may I do this very thing in a way that pleases God and honors Him? That one question, honestly asked and honestly answered, quietly transforms everything it touches.
For when that question is truly brought to bear, the most ordinary and unremarkable things of daily life become a kind of worship offered to God. This is exactly the Scripture's own teaching, not Law's invention: "whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do all to the glory of God," and again, "whatever you do in word or deed, do all in the name of the Lord Jesus." Notice that this is not a matter of piling a heavy new load of extra religious tasks on top of an already full and tiring life — as though devotion meant simply doing more. It is something better: it is the transforming of the whole of the life we already have, so that our eating and our working and our resting and our speaking are all quietly done unto God. Ordinary life, deliberately offered up to Him, becomes holy — not because the tasks change, but because the heart and aim behind them do. The humblest work, done for God, is sacred.
5. Devotion and Holiness Together
Law joined devotion and holiness together in his title and throughout his book, and he was right to, for the two truly belong together and cannot finally be separated. To be holy is to be set apart for God, and to be increasingly conformed to His own character — turning away, deliberately and daily, from sin and worldliness, and growing up into godliness, into love, into humility, into patience, and into every grace that was in Christ. Devotion without this pursuit of holiness would be hollow; holiness without devotion would be cold.
And this is emphatically not the joyless legalism that some readers fear when they hear such a serious call — a grim, anxious, rule-bound keeping of religious regulations to earn approval. Law's aim was the very opposite. It is a life truly and gladly given over to God, and it is precisely there, in that glad self-giving, and nowhere else, that a soul at last finds its real joy, its true rest, and its deepest purpose. Law's whole burden, from beginning to end, was to call the comfortable, nominal Christian higher and further up — to stop settling for a thin, undemanding, Sunday faith that satisfies neither God nor the soul, and to begin taking God, and the whole life He graciously calls us to, with the seriousness that so great a God deserves. It is a call not to misery but to the only life large enough to satisfy a soul made for God.
6. The Cost, the Joy, and the Grace
We should be honest, as Law was, that such serious devotion genuinely costs something, and it is no kindness to pretend otherwise. It means denying ourselves; ordering our time, our money, and our pleasures by God's will rather than by our own preference; steadily resisting the constant, gentle, downward pull of the world around us; and refusing to be content any longer with a comfortable, surface religion that asks little of us. There is a real cross in it. Yet it is, in the end, the only life truly worthy of so great a God, and truly worthy of a soul that was made by Him and for Him; and — this is the great surprise — far from robbing us of happiness, it turns out to be the very path to it. For we were made to love and serve God, and it is only in this wholehearted devotion, and never in half-heartedness, that the restless soul finally finds its rest. A half-hearted religion, in the end, satisfies no one — not God, and not us.
But one thing must be said clearly and unmistakably at the last, lest Law's bracing call be badly misheard and turned into a burden the gospel never meant it to be. This devotion is not a way of earning God's favor or purchasing His acceptance by the strength of our own effort — that would be mere legalism, and it is emphatically not the gospel of grace. Rather, the whole devout life flows out of grace already received. Having been freely and fully saved by grace through faith in Christ, apart from our works, we then give ourselves wholly to God in grateful, answering love — and we are enabled to do even that only by His own Spirit at work within us. The devout life, rightly understood, is therefore not grim, anxious striving to win what we do not have, but glad and restful surrender of ourselves to the God who already loves us — Christ living His life in us, and we living ours for Him. So take your faith seriously, as Law urges; give God not a corner or a compartment of your life but the whole of it; and lean, the entire time, wholly on His grace to live it.
Take Law’s serious call to heart, then, but take it together with the gospel of grace, or it will only crush you. God does ask for the whole of your life — not merely a Sunday corner of it, but all your work, your money, your hours, and your words — and He deserves nothing less than all of it. Yet He asks it not as a hard master demanding payment for His favor, but as a Father who has already given you everything in Christ. So give Him the whole of your life, gladly and without reserve; and give it not to purchase a love you do not yet have, but in grateful answer to a love that is already fully and freely yours. That is the devout life in a sentence: everything laid at His feet, and grace underneath it all.
7. Taking It to Heart
For reflection. Is your religion the whole shape of your life, or a carefully kept compartment beside a life that otherwise looks much like the world's? Bring Law's question to one ordinary area — your money, your time, your leisure: how would it change if you ordered it to please God? And can you hold devotion and grace together — giving God everything, not to earn His love, but out of it?